BAG At Diamond Light Source Proposal Guidance

The UK Catalysis Hub BAG is typically heavily oversubscribed, often by several times the available beamtime. Proposals are generally assessed against four key criteria:

  1. The quality of the underpinning catalysis science
  2. The feasibility and suitability of the proposed XAS measurements
  3. The ability of the group to coordinate and execute the experiments effectively
  4. The extent to which the proposal broadens the user pool and/or brings new areas of catalysis into XAS studies


Panel members act as champions for the proposals they are assigned to review and actively look for their strengths. However, an increasing number of proposals do not provide panel members with sufficient information to fully assess their scientific merit or the justification for the proposed measurements.

The following guidance is intended to help you present your proposal as clearly and effectively as possible.

1) Lay Summary

This section should be short, clear, and accessible. Explain in simple terms what you are studying, why you are studying it, and what experiment you wish to perform.

Common mistakes:

  • The language is too technical or difficult to follow.
  • The scientific justification is overly detailed.
  • The section repeats information provided elsewhere in the proposal.

Keep the detail to a minimum. There are other sections in which you can explain the scientific rationale and experimental approach in depth, so avoid unnecessary repetition.

2) Research Hypothesis

This is one of the proposal’s most important sections. Clearly state the scientific question or hypothesis you will test and explain why XAS is essential to answering it.

Access to synchrotron XAS is extremely limited by international standards, so every proposed measurement needs a clear and compelling justification. As this is a catalysis BAG, we also want to understand the catalytic reaction being investigated and, wherever possible, how the catalysts perform in that reaction. Relevant performance data should be included in the additional figures.

Common mistake:

The most common mistake, and one that is becoming increasingly frequent, is to use this section to explain how XAS works or describe the general information that XAS can provide.

The panel already understands XAS. Instead, focus on your specific catalysts and the scientific question you need XAS to answer. Explain what you expect to learn from the measurement that cannot be established using other approaches.

XAS is an extremely powerful technique, but, like all methods, it has limitations:

(i) This is a per-atom averaging technique, and the spectrum will be an average of all sites within the sample.

(ii) EXAFS cannot distinguish between elements of similar atomic number, especially Z = ±1.

(iii) Overlapping edges from both the element of study and other elements in the matrix can complicate measurements. A full list of edges and their energies can be found here. AI interfaces are very effective for identifying these.

3) Sample Characteristics

In this section, and making full use of the additional information that can be provided in the optional figures, you should demonstrate that you have undertaken appropriate routine characterisation and have compelling evidence that XAS is required to address the scientific question.

Common mistakes:

  • Previous characterisation is not described adequately.
  • The evidence supporting the need for XAS is weak, particularly when the particles are relatively large. Particles larger than a few nanometres can increasingly exhibit predominantly bulk-like characteristics and may provide limited information beyond that obtainable using other methods.

 

4) What is the Current XAFS Resource in Your Group?

The key point here is simply to demonstrate that your group has access to a competent individual who is already trained in XAFS data analysis.

If this expertise is not currently available within the group, explain clearly what arrangements or activities will enable the data to be analysed effectively. This could include collaboration, training, or support from an experienced XAS researcher.

Common mistake:

Providing a detailed description of the data-analysis procedure. This is not required. The panel primarily needs to establish that the necessary expertise and resources are available to obtain meaningful results from the measurements.

5) Please list up to three key publications from the past two years that have involved the use of XAFS (highlight those resulting from a BAG allocation with an asterisk), where available.

In this section, we are simply trying to understand whether your previous XAS time has resulted in publication, especially publications that have used the BAG.

Diamond is funded through the taxpayer, and we have an obligation to try to ensure that impact results from the time used.

We understand that new users will not have this track record and that it takes time from beamtime to publication.

6) Samples

There is no formal limit on the number of samples that can be requested. However, groups are expected to respect the community-access ethos of the BAG and request only those samples that are necessary to answer the scientific question.

Common mistakes:

(i) Not following the instructions in the proposal form

For example, the form explicitly asks you to provide the composition of each sample in weight %. If the panel cannot determine the composition of a sample, they cannot properly assess the feasibility or suitability of the proposed measurements. This can significantly affect prioritisation.

(ii) Using a sample code as a sample name. We need to be clear on what the sample is.

(iii) Requesting large numbers of insufficiently justified samples

Samples should be carefully selected to test the hypothesis described in the preceding sections. An arbitrary series of samples is not, in itself, a compelling scientific justification. Synchrotron XAS measurements are scarce, so judicious sample lists are essential.

The panel will seek to identify which samples are genuinely required to answer the hypothesis and may reduce the number of samples awarded accordingly. A smaller, well-justified sample set is therefore preferable to a large set in which the rationale for individual samples is unclear.

(iv) Poorly describing non-powder samples

Samples that are not powders—such as thin films, electrodes, or other structured materials—are often inadequately described.

Provide sufficient information for the panel to assess the sample and the feasibility of the proposed measurement. For example, include relevant dimensions, composition, loading, substrate or support, and any other characteristics that could affect the XAS measurement.

Do not assume that the panel will be able to fill in missing information. If the panel cannot establish what the sample is or how it will be measured, this can again result in the proposal being ranked lower in the prioritisation process.

7) Other points

Be explicit about any conditions or special handling needed for your samples. Access to a glove box can be arranged; however, please be mindful that this is a shared resource. Moreover, explicitly describing activities such as the use of a glove box provides the panel with the best information for planning and coordinating experiments.